Popular Pig® Podcast

The Real-World Science of Swine Disinfection | Dr. Jose Ramirez

Share this:

About the Guest

Dr. Jose Ramirez is a scientific advisor for Clipper Distributing Company, LLC. Dr. Ramirez developed the first accelerated peroxide (AHP®) formulations which asides from Intervention disinfectant, also include hospital and dental disinfectants, a reuse medical sterilant, an antimicrobial hand wash, and a dairy teat dip. He holds more than 20 issued or pending patents ranging from cleaning & disinfection, to water treatment and chemical process sensors & controls. His first patent was filed in 1999 – the first AHP® formulation.

Dr. Ramirez has more than 25 years of experience in disinfectant formulation development as applied to infection prevention and biosecurity in a variety of markets. He has started two companies based on his inventions and has won several business pitch competitions, including technologies for wastewater processing and wastewater control. He has been featured and interviewed several times in the press.

Dr. Ramirez holds a BS in Mechanical Engineering, and MS and PhD degrees in Chemical Engineering from the University of Colorado at Boulder.

youtube placeholder image

What can you expect to learn from this episode of Popular Pig?

  •  What contact time really means and why the surface has to stay wet.
  •  Why EPA lab testing does not perfectly match the conditions found on a farm.
  •  How cleaning first can lower the pathogen load before disinfectant is applied.
  •  Where worker exposure changes depending on how a disinfectant is applied.
  •  Why truck-wash time, dilution and application steps can change the true cost.

Transcript Disclaimer: This transcript was generated using AI-powered transcription software and may contain errors, including incorrect names, industry terminology, or words that were not accurately captured. For the most accurate representation of the conversation, please refer to the original audio or video recording.

Automatically Transcribed With AI

Matthew Rooda 00:00:00 Welcome to the popular pig podcast. I’m your host Matthew Roda. And joining me today is Doctor Jose Ramirez, who is the scientific advisor to Clipper Distributing and Intervention. Excited to bring you back on the podcast. We had you on talking about the various types of disinfectants and the things to look out for some of the pros and cons, and that way people, when they’re buying a disinfectant, know what they’re signing up for. And I got a lot of really great feedback and a lot of questions about things that they wanted to dive deeper into, such as just going through those differences again, but also the safety components, the truck wash components, and then with Purrs and PED being such big topics for the industry, how they should be considering disinfectants for those particular diseases. So without further ado. Excited to have you back and, welcome.

Jose Ramirez 00:00:50 Thank you very much, Matthew. Yes. Yeah, indeed. I mean, I was, World Pork, a few months back, and, it was incredible the reception that that episode got.

Jose Ramirez 00:00:59 I mean, everybody was commenting on it. As a matter of fact, that, you know, I was sitting at a table with a couple of the attendees to World Pork and they were talking about, you know, how good the episode was. And not knowing that I was the person that was being interviewed by you in that episode. And then all of a sudden, one of the vets just looked over and kind of recognized, oh, wait a minute, you were the guy. Yeah. So, yeah. So I, I think it was very well received and a lot of people listened or viewed it.

Matthew Rooda 00:01:28 I know that for me, even though I had been in the industry, most like most of my life, most of what you shared was educational, because you just you don’t think about it in the way that it’s it’s broken down in the chemistry. And let’s face it, the labels on those bottles are so long and convoluted. You’re not reading the label every time, and sometimes tribal knowledge takes over.

Matthew Rooda 00:01:53 Hey, just pour this much of this into this. Add some water and it becomes a little bit of personal judgment. So it was cool to get a little bit more of the science behind all of it. To start off today, could you give a little bit of a background on yourself again? We’ll go brief this time. If they want the whole background they go the other episode. But just a little bit of your background.

Jose Ramirez 00:02:12 Yeah. So, I just, you know, at the risk of being repetitive, I’m actually by training. By education. I’m. I’m a mechanical engineer. I have a master’s in PhD in chemical engineering, so I come from from it from a totally different side. I’m not I don’t have an animal science or background. and I’ve been in the, let’s say, disinfection industry for, I would say almost 30 years. and my, let’s say, colleague claim to fame was the invention of a disinfectant technology that is based on hydrogen peroxide as the active, the main features being that it’s much more safer to people, and to the environment.

Jose Ramirez 00:02:53 And now, of course, the animals. and as I said last time, this technology was actually developed. towards the end of the 90s. and the focus of that technology was hospital disinfection. So, again, just to reiterate the, the, the technology, it was was mostly focused on human health in the beginnings. But then about maybe 15 years ago, the company decided to expand its reach into adjacent areas like, animal health, like, dentistry, etc.. but the basis of the technology still is the same as the hospital disinfectant product. That, by the way, you are, I would say 50% likely to find in your local hospital for environmental disinfection.

Matthew Rooda 00:03:45 So when we’re diving kind of into the topic, then around the different types of disinfectants and skipping to the point because the last episode would have had a lot of the details in it. We look at Ghouta, how derides, poor oxygen disinfectants. let’s talk a little bit about the difference between those that are more expensive versus those that are cheaper.

Matthew Rooda 00:04:08 And if they do have EPA registration IDs at the end of the day, aren’t they all proven to be effective? And if so, why not focus on cost?

Jose Ramirez 00:04:20 Yeah. Yeah. Correct. That’s that’s a good starting point, Matthew. So, yeah. So when you look at disinfectant technology and by the way, these comments apply across the the board, be it human health or animal health. Okay. But when you look at environmental disinfectants, you are more or less are looking at a, I would say a handful of effective actives. Right. And when I say effective, effective means that they have biocides activity and therefore have the ability to, to destroy. To kill. To reduce log numbers of different types of pathogens. Right. And so generally speaking, you’re looking at probably one of the most known is chlorine or bleach. Right. This is the same thing. then you’re looking at the column next generation oxidizers like, per acetic acid, per oxygen amount of per sulfate, etc.. Although, I think, you know, last time we talked about the nuisance of mono per sulfate, which is actually really a chlorine based product.

Jose Ramirez 00:05:22 then you have what I would say is probably the widest use disinfectant active. which is, short handedly called a quat, which stands for a quaternary ammonium, surfactant. And probably these are, I would say, one of, you know, asides from bleach, probably the second oldest, type of disinfectant, and certainly the most widespread worldwide, both in human and in animal circles. and then you have some other minor categories like aldehyde. You mentioned that in the context of your question. phenolics, and and some other types of, nitrogen based effects. Anyway, so if, if a category like a quaternary ammonium compound is historically proven to be affected by the way. So these were actually first, synthesized, by, the Germans, I would say back in the 30s, 40s was the first generation of quite and they have evolved by, you know, just tweaking the molecule here and there to make it more either hard water resistance to try and give it a broader spectrum of activity, etc., etc., whereby now we talk of fifth generation quads.

Jose Ramirez 00:06:41 So if you look at the development history, there’s actually five generations of advancement in what’s right. and what I’ve seen is actually, some, newer products out there that have come out with a lower cost point that are based on, oddly enough, some of the older generation quartz, you know, second, first, second generation quads. I mean, these are quads that were developed 50, 60 years ago.

Matthew Rooda 00:07:09 So why go back to the basics?

Jose Ramirez 00:07:11 Because these are cheaper molecules, right? Okay. And so if you actually have a use conditions that are let’s say tightly prescribed as they should be on the label of the product, then you can, you can actually get away with passing the required government, you know, EPA tests for disinfection. What do I mean by tightly control? So, first of all, you have to allow for when you’re using a lower generation, what you have to allow for a longer contact time. So you will see some of these products that rely in earlier generation. Quartz will have a contact time of typically ten minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:07:55 Right. That’s a that’s a fairly long contact. What is the contact time mean if you actually read the label. The label says that the surface has to remain wet for that contact time. So you look at the label and some of these products and you will see that, ensure surface remains wet for ten minutes in the case of these, of these older generation type products.

Matthew Rooda 00:08:19 Which depending on what you’re washing, isn’t always practical.

Jose Ramirez 00:08:22 Exactly. And especially when you look at, vertical surfaces. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:08:26 So that’s what I was thinking of.

Jose Ramirez 00:08:27 Exactly. So perhaps if you’re, you know, flooding a particular environment with a lot of solution to ensure that, yeah, the floor is likely going to remain wet for more than ten minutes. But when you actually look at vertical surfaces, if you have, especially if you have a very quick runoff, Right. And let’s say you don’t have, let’s say, a foam phase that actually retards the runoff in the vertical surfaces, then. Yeah, very likely.

Jose Ramirez 00:08:53 And especially in a hot day. Right. Very likely. Your vertical surfaces are not going to remain wet for more than ten minutes.

Matthew Rooda 00:09:00 Especially the underside of, let’s say, a south crate or the underside of a gate in a trailer. Yeah. That underside part isn’t going to remain wet for more than probably, you know, 6 or 7 minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:09:13 Exactly, exactly. Yeah. So, you can see that. Yeah. I mean, it’s great to to have a product that seemingly has a lower cost. but you are trading in other aspects of it, right? So, okay, so maybe it’s a lower cost, but now you have to make sure that the surface remains wet for ten minutes. And because if it doesn’t, you are not going to achieve the, reduction in pathogen that the label promise you that you will. This is. This is a big issue, right? So, you know, if as a matter of example. Right. So let’s say that because you’ll say, well, all these products are reviewed by EPA, right.

Jose Ramirez 00:09:53 And so they are all they should be meeting the basic efficacy benchmarks. Right. And yes, that’s true. They have to pass a very rigorous, biocides efficacy test, which is very well prescribed. And everybody does the same test. Right. And however you have to remember, these tests are actually run in the laboratory under very carefully controlled conditions. Right. And because like it’s it’s impractical for the US EPA that has a jurisdiction over disinfectants to implement FDA style clinical trials.

Matthew Rooda 00:10:27 Yeah. In every environment.

Jose Ramirez 00:10:28 Right. And so which, by the way, the Chinese have done so. So in China, if you have to register a disinfectant in China, there’s a phase one where you where you actually test the disinfectant in the lab, but there is a clinical you have to find three farms. Yeah. And then apply the disinfectant for for a certain period of time in those three farms. And then measure, you know, you have to sort of conclude that the outbreaks had actually been reduced. I mean, it’s wow, it’s very registering a veterinary disinfectant in China is harder than registering a human disinfectant in China is interesting.

Jose Ramirez 00:11:01 Yeah. But I think they maybe they learn something about, you know, when they had the, their African swine fever, problems.

Matthew Rooda 00:11:10 So then are you at a point then where at the end of the day, they all work? Yeah. But there’s a practicality to it of you. We talked about the drying, but are there other components to practicality as you look at more data, generations of these quotes that that come into play? and if so, what does that look like.

Jose Ramirez 00:11:34 Right. That, that that that to complete your the the question that could affect your actual results in the field? Yes. Correct. Yes. Exactly.

Matthew Rooda 00:11:41 So both in the practicality of just doing it and the amount of time and the operational impact, but also the efficacy of reducing the disease.

Jose Ramirez 00:11:49 Exactly. And that’s a great addition, by the way, on, on, on sort of the operational aspects to it because yes, there’s a lot there as well. But yeah. So let’s since we’ve been talking about efficacy, right.

Jose Ramirez 00:12:00 And we’ve established number one that all these actives that I mentioned, including quads, they’re very well documented and proven to be efficacious from a societal point of view. Right. So this is not this is not, there’s nothing that is not known about their efficacy. And it’s very well accepted and documented. then the actual formulated product itself, if it has an EPA registration number, which you can see on the label, it means that it has passed all the rigorous efficacy benchmarks that the US EPA requires. Okay. But remember, these these benchmarks are based on carefully controlled laboratory tests. Okay. now, just to give you an idea of the discrepancy between the laboratory test and, real field conditions, right. So a disinfectant is approved for one step cleaner disinfection. In other words, that the disinfect then remains active under soil conditions. That’s basically the one step clean disinfection means. If you actually run the laboratory, the laboratory test with a 5% soil load. Okay. What does that mean? It means that when you run the test, okay, you add to the inoculum to the to the bacterial inoculum that you’re using in your test.

Jose Ramirez 00:13:25 You you you add 95% inoculum and you add 5%, soil. And what is that soil that soil is prescribing the method to. And it should be bovine serum. Okay. So you’re basically testing under quote unquote soil conditions. And this is the accepted standard for everybody. We all this is also intervention is also tested like this. Right. with a 5% bovine serum soil load. And that’s supposed to mean that the disinfectant works under dirty conditions. Okay.

Matthew Rooda 00:13:58 Now, if it doesn’t work under dirty conditions, then what’s the point?

Jose Ramirez 00:14:01 But then what happens in the field? What happens in the field. Right. So I mean, first of all, very rarely, unless you’re sort of disinfecting, surgical equipment or anything, your soil is not going to be like serum. There’s soil is going to be feces. Yeah. Right. Or, you know, or excessive hardness or, you know, urine. you know, inorganic organic compounds.

Matthew Rooda 00:14:26 With biofilms and everything else going on. You’re probably not at 5% either, right? Exactly.

Matthew Rooda 00:14:30 A little higher, right?

Jose Ramirez 00:14:31 Right, right. And so, So. So this is where in practice you would like to have some degree of assurance or some degree of risk management, if you will. When we’re talking about the disinfection power of the disinfectant that you’re using. Right. You’d want to allow for some of these more realistic conditions. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:14:52 And the power is that formulation driven or is that more like the modern approach of like because you talked about you have the more dated quotes or the more modern quotes more powerful, right. Okay.

Jose Ramirez 00:15:05 Exactly. And so the power is both, active, ingredient driven. And like you said, the, the the latter generation quotes are more powerful disinfectants than the older generation, but it’s also formulation driven. So whatever you put in that mixture can actually enhance or detract from the activity. That’s what they call, you know, a positive or negative synergy.

Matthew Rooda 00:15:27 And everything that’s in that formulation has to be on the label. how does that work?

Jose Ramirez 00:15:33 Not necessarily.

Jose Ramirez 00:15:34 Not necessarily. So, the from the EPA point of view, the only thing that has to be on the label is the active ingredients. Okay. So that’s why when you look at, you know, a concentrate that is quite good or aldehyde, you’ll see those two listed, you know, quaternary ammonium. Or maybe it’ll say maybe diethyl methyl benzyl chlorine chloride ammonium. That’s that’s a quote. Right. And it’ll say you know, 8% or whatever. And then it’ll say like maybe gluten aldehyde, you know, whatever, 3% or something. So you’ll see only those two ingredients. That doesn’t mean that those are the only ingredients in there. Interesting. Okay. Which is okay. There’s nothing nefarious about that. Sometimes when you go to the SDS, you will see some other additional ingredients there. And it’s just basically the the accepted regulations. As far as safety declarations, you know, some ingredients that by themselves are hazardous. They have to be listed there. They might be at concentrations in your disinfectant bottle that are non-hazardous, which is most most of the time, as is the case.

Jose Ramirez 00:16:36 So anyway. But no. No one. Now, now you have some states. For example, California has a regulation where where I believe it’s for consumer products. You actually have to disclose all the ingredients. Okay. And so it’s either on the label or you have to point to a website. Okay. But I believe this is mostly for consumer products. and I think many states and many companies have proactively done that. So if you, you know, companies like S.C. Johnson or Procter and Gamble, you know, are big consumer companies. Yeah. You can any product you can go to there, you can scan the QR code, or you can go to the website and exactly know what are the listed ingredients. And they have to be listed by order of concentration. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:17:16 I think McDonald’s said they did that because people are always like what’s in what’s in the ingredient. So they did it and they said the amount of people who would go to the site after they made it available was like nonexistent.

Jose Ramirez 00:17:25 Oh, there’s a there’s a lot of especially the consumers are much more highly educated now with regards to that safety. Right. And so yeah. Yeah. So definitely. But going back to the original question. So yeah. So, so so the efficacy is a matter of not just the active ingredient but also the mixture. Right. And so now so what what what what are the implications of this. So it means that if you have number one, if you have an active ingredient or a mixture that, is either easily inactivated by soil conditions, okay, or is not, robust to soil conditions or itself doesn’t have high detergent. In other words, that it can actually remove soils. Okay. Then of course your efficacy is going to suffer, right? that’s number one.

Matthew Rooda 00:18:20 So based on what you’re saying, because for everybody listening, I’m learning as we go here, if I’m using an older generation quote. I probably need to pair that with a stronger or a detergent. Or how does that does that? Does that matter at all?

Jose Ramirez 00:18:34 That’s a great oh you’re seeing you’re thinking like a formulator.

Jose Ramirez 00:18:38 Yeah. Yeah. But the the the the the problem is and this applies only to quotes. Okay. Remember that we said at last session that quotes were positively charged molecules. Right. And that in nature most environmental surfaces and soils are negatively charged. Right. So that means that there is an there’s an affinity between soils and the quote. Therefore, the quote very easily binds to soils, which means that then it’s unavailable to kill. Yeah. Okay.

Matthew Rooda 00:19:11 So neutralizes.

Jose Ramirez 00:19:12 It. Exactly. So the more soil you have, the easier it will be to inactivate the quad. Right. This is this is a problem. And so you can say. Well, but you mentioned before that quotes are surfactants. And so you know, remember a detergent is a surfactant. So you could argue, well, you know, maybe a quart solution or you could add in your mixture some detergent so that you have, you have you have detergent, detergent power in it. Right. But with a quiet you.

Matthew Rooda 00:19:40 But that would increase cost, right.

Jose Ramirez 00:19:42 It wouldn’t of course. Exactly. It would. It would increase costs. It would increase cost. but then what what what ends up happening is, is that, when you, when you apply a co-op based product in a one step clean, disinfect product, you might be able to pass the laboratory, quote unquote dirty test. Remember, it was only 5% bovine serum. But probably and I think there’s literature out there showing that in real soiled conditions where you have higher levels and 5%, and when your soil is not serum, but it’s actual feces and so on. the court just doesn’t perform right. And so. Yeah. So on the one hand, you have yes, you know, the EPA says that or certifies that, you know, the the clot based product is able to pass in quote unquote, dirty conditions. But remember what the definition of dirty conditions is to EPA, right? It’s not the same as it is to an animal science person.

Matthew Rooda 00:20:46 Fair. So you have a working product that has a label with likely these things on it, but you’re probably not going and reading.

Matthew Rooda 00:20:58 And so the drying time, how much soil you do expect for it to handle, there’s all these components that no layperson is ever going to know how to take into account.

Jose Ramirez 00:21:10 Know exactly now. So if you ask me and so so let’s say I was in charge of a farm and then, yeah, let’s say corporate told me, listen, you have to use this product, which is a quote based product. You have to use it because we got a good deal. And it’s, you know, it lowers our cost. Okay. So if I was a, a a, let’s say a chemical nerd, and I was managing my farm, I would say, okay, I’ll do that. But here’s what I’m going to do to make sure that we minimize our risk here. So the first thing I’m going to do is I’m going to implement a thorough cleaning step. So I’m going to go find a nice, non ionic detergent, preferably because we’re going to use a quat. I’ll explain why but we use we’re going to use a nice detergent to make sure that we clean everything first.

Jose Ramirez 00:21:54 Okay. So by the way if you actually do proper cleaning you already are reducing the number of, log numbers of any pathogen present by anywhere between 1 to 2. So if you start it with, let’s say, I don’t know, let’s say a million viral particles per centimeter squared, just by cleaning, you reduce that to maybe Be 100,000, maybe 10,000.

Matthew Rooda 00:22:20 Just remove cleaning means just with water.

Jose Ramirez 00:22:23 Well, with water in it.

Matthew Rooda 00:22:24 And a detergent.

Jose Ramirez 00:22:25 Okay. Yeah. You know, because the detergent is that effective? Right. And many people don’t realize that that cleaning in itself can reduce between 1 and 2. So when I say one and two logs, that’s 10 to 100 times. So if you start with a million viral particles on the surface, right. When you when you reduce two logs, you’re going to end up with 10,000. That’s a big difference right. And so now when you apply a disinfectant that has 3 or 4 log reduction, 10,000 becomes one particle. And we’re talking about these viruses that maybe you need 10 or 50 particles to get infected.

Jose Ramirez 00:22:58 So if you have one particle your chance of infection is exactly right. So that’s one thing. So what we do is implement a very thorough cleaning. Okay. Then we can use the quaternary ammonium. Right. And then when we use the quaternary ammonium I am making sure in particular that we flood the horizontal surfaces properly. Because remember we need that ten minute contact time. And I am very vigilant about the vertical surfaces, especially the surfaces that the animals typically have contact with. Right. So maybe I don’t know what that is a meter or whatever it is, you know, three feet below, right. making sure that those vertical surfaces are always wet for those ten minutes because the minute they dry and it’s not been ten minutes, now you have potentially, you know, a higher, bacterial or viral load there.

Matthew Rooda 00:23:49 Or is everybody about ten minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:23:52 So, ten minutes was actually the standard. And this is an interesting story, by the way. So ten minutes was traditionally the standard for the industry, right.

Jose Ramirez 00:24:03 Because the, prevalent technology when all these regulations were written, you know, or going back maybe 30, 40 years, right. The prevalent technology was quartz. Right. And so all these regulations, not just animal, but human. Remember, human has always been a little bit ahead of the animal space. But the human disinfectant regulations, they were written for ten minutes.

Matthew Rooda 00:24:31 Were they written for ten minutes? Because that’s what’s proven effective. Or are they written for ten minutes? Because that’s what everybody could handle with that version of a quad. Exactly.

Jose Ramirez 00:24:38 Okay, that was it. So in other words, as always, right. You know, regulators are not going to put the bar too high so that they put people out of business. Right. So, you know, it’s this.

Matthew Rooda 00:24:49 Is that makes a lot of.

Jose Ramirez 00:24:50 Sense. That’s just how capitalism work. Right. Yeah. So,

Matthew Rooda 00:24:53 If that’s the best it could do, why set the bar so high that none of them pass?

Jose Ramirez 00:24:57 Well, exactly.

Jose Ramirez 00:24:58 Then now you have a problem, right? Now what happened? So back in 1998, when we were, you know, a very small outfit out of Mississauga, Ontario, the company is called Virus technology, still called virus technologies. When we were looking at these disinfection technologies, one of the insights and actually this insight came from, actually the current principal of the company is still there, Randy Pilon. brilliant marketing guy. He said, wait a minute. You know, everybody’s working with ten minutes, and we got this powerful disinfectant technology that is passing, you know, these tests at five minutes and in the ready to do version is passing it at one minute. Let’s just flip this thing on its head and come out with a very fast contact time disinfectant. Yeah, right. And the argument was, by the way, these surfaces were seeing that they dry before ten minutes. So it’s like, you know, there is a risk there, right? And so we were the first, company that actually asked for registrations below ten minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:26:09 And so when the human, health disinfection technology. That is, by the way, it’s the same. More or less the same as what is an intervention today. When that was registered with the US EPA, it was one of the first ones to be registered with a contact time less than ten minutes. It was registered with a contact time of five minutes. And that completely revolutionized it. So. So when I think about it, I just realized this was one of the biggest factors for our success in. Remember we started the company focus on human health, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. What was the biggest factor in our success? Yes, I think, you know, I mentioned before in our previous podcast, The Safety right. There was a, there was a, there was a the the market was asking for safer disinfectants from a human health point of view, but also from an environmental point of view. Right. But actually it was also the shorter contact time, right? There was no.

Matthew Rooda 00:27:00 There was an operational benefit and an efficacy benefit because you didn’t take on the operational risk of needing to wait the ten minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:27:07 Exactly, exactly. And now it’s funny because now you look at especially in the human health environment where I said maybe, probably human health, maybe as far as environmental disinfection, there are probably 10 or 15 years ahead of of of us in animal health. It’s a, it’s an arms race or lower contact times. So so now you have it’s a it’s very common that you have a lot of ready to use products that are one minute 30s. It’s just like, you know, everybody’s trying to look as short as possible, right? Yeah. And I think I can say I think we started that back in 1998 because that, that that was not happening at all.

Matthew Rooda 00:27:41 That’s pretty cool. I think I mentioned last time there was a colleague of mine who had invented a, a disinfectant that would turn blue when the contact time was a certain length. So people knew when they could wipe it off because they were struggling with people disinfecting, and they’re going and wiping off all the surfaces.

Matthew Rooda 00:28:00 But you weren’t actually getting these these labs in surgical rooms and all the equipment truly disinfected.

Jose Ramirez 00:28:06 Yeah, yeah, yeah. So I mean, it’s, it just goes to, to show if you have a solution for a practical, everyday problem. Right. And in this case, it was that, you know, certainly the, the people in charge of infection control in hospitals, you know, the infection control nurses, they know, I mean, because they’re doing this day to day and they know that these surfaces are drying in less than ten minutes. Right. But yet the product says you remain wet for ten minutes. Now in a, in a, in a, let’s say in a critical environment, let’s say the operating room. I bet you that probably the solution that the, the infection control nurses would apply was, well, let’s just reapply. You know, and so now okay. But now you’re using twice the product. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:28:46 Which the person making the buying decision isn’t factoring in that they’re using it twice.

Jose Ramirez 00:28:50 Exactly right.

Matthew Rooda 00:28:51 So you guys are using this a lot right. Yeah.

Jose Ramirez 00:28:53 Right. Right, right.

Matthew Rooda 00:28:54 It must be really good. Oh right.

Jose Ramirez 00:28:57 Right. But see, that doesn’t happen in the farm environment. Right, right. you know, and I would argue it doesn’t even happen in the non-critical areas of the hospital. Maybe it happens in the surgical suites, right? But yeah, this is an important thing. And it’s it goes to your point of understanding the label. Right. And so yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:29:16 So to that point though, if quotes are as margins like from a health and safety standpoint, how did the generation of quote and all the other things that go into it? How does safety change. Yeah. Through each generation.

Jose Ramirez 00:29:32 Yeah, that’s a great question. And we kind of drilled into that last time. Right. And you were asking me. Yeah. You know, what was what was one of the success factors. And I was mentioning the safety the health and safety aspects, certainly in human health.

Jose Ramirez 00:29:44 Right. Because remember, there was a lot of science, scientific studies in the literature that began to emerge, I would say probably since, maybe late 80s and then throughout the 90s that, a lot of these quotes were Amazons, and.

Matthew Rooda 00:30:01 I mean, some labels even have wearing, like, masks. Yeah. As a part and to safely apply. Yes. And I was shocked because that just wasn’t something. Yeah. I’d ever thought was there.

Jose Ramirez 00:30:13 Well and then so. So this goes to the, to the question of okay if these if these materials are not safe for, for for people to use. Right. If their asthma. Right. Then why does EPA allow its use. Right. Well EPA. I mean they’re you know, they have to be reasonable. Right. So they allow their use as long as you are implementing the proper precautionary measures.

Matthew Rooda 00:30:37 Written on the label that people don’t read.

Jose Ramirez 00:30:40 Exactly written, that people don’t read. Yeah. And so that’s why when you start looking at these labels of some of these co-op based products, yes, it makes reference to PPE equipment and respirators and type K type and respirator, I mean, a whole bunch of stuff that I don’t even I had to Google.

Jose Ramirez 00:30:56 What the hell is and you know, sorry, what the heck is a is a is a is an N type respirator, right. You know. And so technically, that’s what you should be using when you’re working with the product. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:31:07 So, so if you’re, you’re looking at quotes and the generations of quotes trying to layman this, that the cheaper the product, likely the further back. I’m going into the generation of quote. Yes. And the further back I’m going into the generation of quote, the more drying time is necessary for it to work, as well as the more PPE I need to provide to actually use the product. Is that fair?

Jose Ramirez 00:31:35 yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:31:36 On the latter side there with the PPE and.

Jose Ramirez 00:31:38 No. So okay, so so so what I would like to I would say, 80% of it is, is true, but with a, with a, with a qualifier. Right. So from the safety point of view, I wouldn’t say that the older or newer generation quads are more or less safe.

Jose Ramirez 00:31:58 I would say the safety is probably the same. Okay.

Matthew Rooda 00:32:02 So then what drives the difference in the need for respirators and everything else?

Jose Ramirez 00:32:08 Well, I mean, as a general rule, any product that has a quote will have all these warnings. We’ll have all these respiratory warnings.

Matthew Rooda 00:32:18 Okay. But anyway it really has to have that.

Jose Ramirez 00:32:21 Exactly. Okay. Yeah. now it also depends on its on its mode of use. Right. So for example, in the consumer world and actually many of these are used by vets to, let’s say disinfect their trucks. Right. In the consumer world you have these, you know, brand name wipes. Everybody knows the brand name. So these are consumer brands. So we can say, you know Lysol Clorox right.

Matthew Rooda 00:32:44 Okay. Those are the type of quote.

Jose Ramirez 00:32:46 Yeah. And those are those are quote based wipes. Right. But the concentration of the quote number one on those wipes is very low. And number two, the application mode is not generating very fine droplets, so you’re not spraying it in very fine droplets.

Jose Ramirez 00:33:02 That, by the way, are very easy for these droplets to make it deep into the respiratory tract. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:33:09 So you’re not eating them. So like right. You’re fine.

Jose Ramirez 00:33:12 Exactly right. And so so you know, when you apply this wipe and you clean your, you know, your, your steering wheel and your and your the inside of your truck with a swipe. The risk is virtually zero because the route of exposure is not conducive to the hazard profile of the you know, so the quad is an Amazon, but you’re not the conditions for inspiring it. Yeah. For inhaling it are not there if you use it as a wipe. Right. Which is totally different if you use it in an enclosed environment and you’re actually.

Matthew Rooda 00:33:40 Blasting the crap out of a room. Exactly.

Jose Ramirez 00:33:42 Yeah, exactly. Because if you look at the, you know, the size distribution of those droplets, there’s going to be a lot of these droplets that are less than 100 micrometers, less than ten micrometers.

Matthew Rooda 00:33:51 Heck, usually you’re spraying the ceiling above you if you’re doing it right and it’s dropping and it’s all over the place.

Jose Ramirez 00:33:56 Yeah, yeah yeah. So I mean, and there’s been in Europe, actually, there’s been a lot of, papers written about, what exposure to farmers in aerosolized ation and the risks of that. And sort of it’s been shown that the cases of asthma in farms that use quads for, you know, spraying are much higher than those that do not use robots, you know. So it is well known. And that’s why you see those, precautions on the label.

Matthew Rooda 00:34:29 I’ll tell my wife that that’s what I blame. My poor mile time on the next time I’m running. Yeah, yeah, that’ll definitely affect the running time, for sure. Yeah, yeah. So what? How does this impact truck washes? So when you think about all the work that’s being done in there, I mean, I’m thinking about some of the labeling where you’re seeing the ten minute drying time, you got to wear all this equipment, but at the same time make some ask you to even do it a second time.

Matthew Rooda 00:34:54 And at the end of the day, you have so many trucks that are waiting to go through these washes. we get more into that operational challenge of if I’m going to have to disinfect a truck twice for it to work, or wait an extra ten, five minutes over X amount of trucks sooner or later, even if it’s free. Is that really worth it?

Jose Ramirez 00:35:15 Yeah. I mean, that’s a great point. I mean, when when you when you, when you look at a product that on the label has a requirement for double application right now that that has.

Matthew Rooda 00:35:27 To do some have that.

Jose Ramirez 00:35:28 Yeah. Yeah. There’s a matter of fact, some of these products that are based on sort of earlier generation, quote, technology. and you remember we talked about the some of these products that had quart and a gluten aldehyde mixture. And matter of fact, you started your discussion with that type of product. if you recall, the reason they combine these two actives is to increase, number one, the spectrum of activity against different classes of microorganisms, because the quads are well documented, that have certain gaps.

Jose Ramirez 00:36:02 and number two is to fortify the disinfection action. Right. And so in many cases, you might be able, for certain class of organisms not have to wait to ten minutes. Maybe you can do with five. I don’t know if there’s commercial examples of that here in the United States, but certainly in Europe there are products that have a gluten aldehyde and quite mix, and they have lower contact times than ten minutes. And the reason is because that gluten aldehyde really fortifies the, the efficacy. Right. but anyway, the practical implication of having, the requirement on the label that you need two steps, let’s say, to process or to disinfect the trailer. you know, has the obvious cost implications that you’re using twice the product. Right. Then like you mentioned and has the operational impact that now it probably takes you twice as much to disinfect the given truck. Right. So now your throughput as far as trucks per day is affected. So these are kind of obvious ones right now. When you start thinking as to why would that instruction be on the label.

Jose Ramirez 00:37:08 Right. There has to be a performance or an efficacy reason. Right. And you know, I don’t know what the reason is, but you could speculate as to what the reason could be. You know, is it that, the product is specially sensitive to soil conditions and therefore you have to have a first step where you sort of reduce the level of soil on the trailer so that then when you apply the second step, the disinfectant isn’t as effected by the soil because the soil level has been reduced prior. Maybe. Is it because, I don’t know. There has to be an allowance for the some of the surfaces that do not remain wet for ten minutes. And so maybe, you know, you use that first step. Maybe some part of the trailer wasn’t entirely wet for ten minutes. And then maybe just to make sure that you reduce your risk, you come up with a second application. I don’t know, because these things are, you know, in general terms are, let’s say additive or linear, right? So if you let’s say if you have a step one where you reduce the the load of going back to our example of a million viral particles, right.

Jose Ramirez 00:38:23 If you do a step one where you reduce from 1 million to 10,000 in ten minutes, yeah, you can then do a replication and then you reduce from 10,000 to 1. Right. So that’s that’s fair. So but I don’t I don’t know the reason the, the truth of the matter is, is that the, it is on the label those instructions for, you know, treating a trailer with a step one and then a step two, it’s on the label. And so remember.

Matthew Rooda 00:38:47 And it’s easy math to know if I have to do two steps on a trailer, it’s not worth it. Yeah, I think the math would be obvious enough if I have to go do it twice. you could give it to me for free. Right. And it’s not worth it.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:00 And I bet you, I bet you that if you go out in the field and look at the truck washers that are using this product, I don’t think they’re doing the two steps.

Matthew Rooda 00:39:11 I’d be surprised.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:12 Right. And so then what does that mean now.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:15 So it either means that well, first of all, here’s a very obvious implication, right. This is stated in the Code of Federal Regulations. Right. If you are using a disinfectant not in accordance to the instructions on the label, this is considered quote unquote, unlawful. You know, this is a this is a word I’m always scared of.

Matthew Rooda 00:39:38 Seriously. So if I’m using a disinfectant and I’m not following the label. Yeah, I’m breaking the law.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:43 Yeah, yeah yeah, yeah. So I think there’s a disclaimer on the EPA register product label. It says using products are not in accordance to label instruction is unlawful.

Matthew Rooda 00:39:53 Or something like oh no. Okay. I’ve seen it on different types of products. So I know what you’re talking about.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:57 Yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:39:57 So anyway.

Jose Ramirez 00:39:58 This is for the lawyers in the room. I mean, but anyway, that’s just starting there.

Matthew Rooda 00:40:01 Driving past, if I was working in a cell farm and someone came in and arrested me because I did it wrong. Yeah.

Jose Ramirez 00:40:08 so. So, anyway, like I said, this is a theoretical. It’s true. I mean, it is legal. So. So this is for the lawyers, right? But, in reality, you, you know, maybe this is this explains right now that there is, 2 or 3 years worth of field experience with some of these quite only more economical products where sites have switched to save cost. And yet, you know, a few months down the road, they actually have a PDV or Pers outbreak and say, what the heck, you know what’s going on, Right? And then they say, you know what? Forget about it. Let’s just switch back to what we were using before. You know, and maybe the reason is because in many instances, while you’re not doing the two steps and therefore maybe either the disinfectant is being inactivated by sort of the soil load.

Matthew Rooda 00:41:01 That.

Jose Ramirez 00:41:01 Wasn’t exactly or surface. Certain critical surfaces are not being maintained wet for the ten minutes that the disinfectant required.

Matthew Rooda 00:41:11 And most likely you’re not doing it twice.

Jose Ramirez 00:41:14 Yeah, exactly.

Matthew Rooda 00:41:15 Right, right. And then at the I think we talked about last time to your applicator rate like that’s a component in a variable in this too is are you actually applying it. Of course. Like because that’s I think when you go from truck wash to truck wash, they’re not all of course, dialed in equally.

Jose Ramirez 00:41:32 Yeah. The dilution the dilution factor. Right. Yes, exactly. And I think we told the stories before that, you know, when I was trying to learn about farms and visiting farms, I don’t think I ever found one that was actually diluting properly. So I mean.

Matthew Rooda 00:41:44 You weren’t necessarily I mean, I’ve disinfected a lot. I watched a lot of barns, watched a lot of trailers, and as a kid, and there wasn’t a lot of training on the dilution factor. No, no, it just wasn’t a part of what you were. It was it was set where it was set and you didn’t touch it.

Matthew Rooda 00:41:59 Yeah. And you had no idea what it should have been.

Jose Ramirez 00:42:02 Yeah. And a lot of the, the, the the manufacturers of power washing equipment. Well, first of all, now you have specialized sort of, you know, agricultural, you know, call it the power washing equipment. And so there’s some actually some very good companies that sort of document that very well. And, you know, and then they talk about that, but in many cases, the, the use of a, dilution tip, the use of a, what they call a of interior, a doctor. Right. is actually external to the, to the unit. Right. And so, you know, it’s typically, let’s say upstream from the system of pipes that cover the barn. Right. Yep. And people. Many people don’t know that inside that, dilution, device or a doctor is actually a small, orifice that determines what that ratio is going to be. And if that orifice is clogged, if the orifice is not correct for what the disinfectant dilution should be, then then then, yeah, you’re not you’re either going to be using too much or you’re going to be using too little.

Jose Ramirez 00:43:06 Right. Yeah. And so if people decide to switch a disinfectant that maybe before the disinfectant was one ounce per gallon, but now it’s half an ounce per gallon, and they decide to switch because it’s cheaper. But then you didn’t go and adjust the and change the orifice that’s inside your dilution. The you know, you’re a doctor now. You’re applying the dilution incorrectly. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:43:25 Well, so I think the number I think it’s like three bucks a pig for people who want to go and build truck washes. Ensure every truck is washed. I think at one of the recent events when the industry was talking through, maybe we require truck washes because not everybody does require it. They’re like, yeah, it’s a it’s a few bucks a pig. So I think I got that right. If I’m spending $3 per pig and taking, building, putting in the capital to build truck washes and they’re leaving and they’re not even disinfected because of all the reasons we’ve talked about. Like, at that point you’re wasting three bucks a pick.

Matthew Rooda 00:44:05 Yeah. Right. Because if if it’s not disinfected, it’s not it’s not disinfected. Right. Can can you look at it black and white or is it is it grayer?

Jose Ramirez 00:44:15 It’s gray. But it’s a great point that you’re making. So I assume that the $3 a pig is sort of the agglomerative cost of the capital investment, the labor, etc., etc., and then disinfectant and so on. And so therefore, you know, you have a substantial investment in infrastructure and labor to ensure that you are minimizing the risk of infection. Right. so it’s a little bit of like this is actually the definition of a weak link, right? Yeah. So so so so let’s say that, you know, you have designed your, a washing bay and you have the right equipment and everything is proper. You’ve used sort of, you know, professional engineering talent to, to, to design that. And everything is proper. You’ve hired the right crew, you’ve trained the crew and they’re trained and so on.

Jose Ramirez 00:45:03 but now in which in the component or the link, that is really the lowest cost, because when you think about it, you know, the amortisation cost of the plant and then the cost of the labor, those are I would say those are more significant costs, right. Yes. But in the smaller cost, which is the chemical disinfect, then you actually cut corners. Yeah. You’re rendering that whole investment, ineffective because you’re not really reducing the risk to the levels that you’re expecting.

Matthew Rooda 00:45:30 My mind goes to, I’m thinking of you’ve got a a building where you build. Built a fence. You have gates and you hire security guards. But you only put a security guard at every other gate. It’s like, well, yeah, we built. We built a fence. We have the gates. But you’re not really thoroughly protecting every part of it. So now you have those weak links. Exactly. People get in and now we’re like, why, why, why are people getting in? Well, we we kind of stopped right towards the end.

Matthew Rooda 00:46:05 Like, all we needed to do was just a little more and the whole place was secured. But we’re cutting a corner in this little spot, and now we’re letting it in.

Jose Ramirez 00:46:15 That’s a great analogy. So yes, I agree 100%. Yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:46:18 So what about to kind of continue towards PDV and Pers with the work that you guys are doing, an intervention to kind of move through the chemistry and the safety and the truck wash component. How are you? How does it impact those two diseases?

Jose Ramirez 00:46:37 Yeah. So here I’d like to retake the, the the discussion line that we had about, let’s say disinfectant power. Okay. because clearly. Right. You know, the more powerful disinfectant that you’re using and I mean power from, from the point of view of ability to reduce the number of viable particles by the greatest number. Right. So let’s say, is not the same. if you have a disinfectant. just to give you a concrete example. Right. For virus vital activity, the EPA says that you have to reduce.

Jose Ramirez 00:47:17 I think it’s like three log numbers of viruses. Three log means a thousand times. So if you have 10,000 viral particles at the end of the test, with the required contact time, you will end up with ten viral particles. Okay. If you end up with ten or less, then you’ve passed the EPA test. Okay. So if if, if, if you need let’s say if you start with 10,000 to get to ten. If you need ten minutes. Okay. That’s a certain type of performance. But if you start at 10,000 to get to ten, you only need five minutes. Clearly, that’s a more powerful disinfectant, right? And this is what we have here. So when you look at PDM purse claims on the label again I always go back to the label. That’s why you have to go by. Right. Some of these lower generation quote based products have a contact time requirement for Pers and PDV, which is ten minutes. Okay. Now when you look at sort of a newer technology like intervention, you will see that across the board no matter what the virus, the contact time is five minutes.

Jose Ramirez 00:48:27 Okay. So that tells you two things. One is, is that the the the technology the disinfectant technology in in, in in a product like intervention is much more powerful because you’re able to reduce the viable viral particles, by the same amount in lower contact time. Okay. Which by the way, if you if you flip the variable, what does that mean? It means that for a given amount of time, you will be able to reduce the number of viral particles by a greater amount with the intervention technology than the old quant technology.

Matthew Rooda 00:49:05 Right? So if it can do the same thing in five that it takes in ten, if intervention is given ten, it’s doing far more. Exactly. Okay.

Jose Ramirez 00:49:13 Exactly right.

Matthew Rooda 00:49:14 So every minute above five is gravy. It’s extra coverage.

Jose Ramirez 00:49:18 Yeah. As extra coverage is reduced risk. Right. And so so if you start with, you know again you know a million viral particles and you’re able to reduce it to 1000 in 5 minutes, while in ten minutes you’re going to be less than one particle or one particle.

Jose Ramirez 00:49:37 So you see that, you know, the, the, the, the level of comfort if you’re able to, you know, maintain the surface for ten minutes, it’s going to be much greater with a more powerful disinfectant. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:49:50 So. So from the production side, more practically, from my point of view, is the industry is constantly dealing with trying to figure out where are these breaks coming from. Yeah. And it’s like, if you can you can almost check the box on if you just use a more powerful disinfectant, we can at least be assured that’s not where it’s coming from. Yes, but it’s not just the power. It’s also simplicity of application and some of the other components.

Jose Ramirez 00:50:20 Many factors. Yeah, yeah. And I always like to put it in terms of simple number so that people can understand. And so okay, some of them, if there’s a virologist listening to this, they’re going to say, wow, this guy doesn’t know what he’s talking about. I get I don’t know by memory what is the infectious dose for Pers or PDV.

Jose Ramirez 00:50:37 The vets out there, they surely know that out of the top of their head. And I guess I should have prepared better. But anyway, just to give you an example. Okay, typically, you, you could have, let’s say per mil or per centimeter squared, you could have very easily 10 million viral particles of pers or PDB. Right. And how and I don’t know what the infectious does, but but typically for many viruses the infectious dose could be around 100 to 10 viral particles. Meaning that if I if a pig ingests more than 100, if they ingest 200 viral particles, they will they will get sick, most likely. Okay, that’s what the infectious does mean. And so in other words, to prevent infection, you have to you know, you have to you have to you have to reduce the load From, let’s say, 10 million or 1 million viral particles per centimeter squared down to less than 100. Right. So that’s, you know, that’s from, from 10 million to to 100.

Jose Ramirez 00:51:36 That’s about what. That’s five logs. Right. So that’s 100,000 times. Right. And so remember the disinfectants under the laboratory conditions, they’re only required to reduce it by a thousand times three logs. Right. And so in practice there’s a little bit of a disconnect there. Right. Because the environmental loads are much higher. Right. This is why when you actually read any animal science manual or book, they say you have to clean first and then you disinfect.

Matthew Rooda 00:52:07 Yeah. And in some of these cases then you need to clean first. Depending on what solution you’re using you may also need to detergent right. And then disinfect right. Because you got to get that what the viral load low enough so that when you do disinfect, it gets below that 100. Exactly. And then if let’s say yeah, you get it to 90. Right on the edge there. But it dries for eight minutes and not ten. Well, I might be stuck with a thousand still. Exactly.

Jose Ramirez 00:52:36 Okay, exactly. So it’s a combination.

Jose Ramirez 00:52:38 So this this sort of.

Matthew Rooda 00:52:39 Just becomes a math problem. Yeah. That we’re typically not.

Jose Ramirez 00:52:43 And it’s a very it’s very simple when you look at it that way. Right. And so so so yeah. So so when number one when you use a disinfectant that is a very good cleaner detergent. Okay. And remember quotes are not clean good cleaner detergents. Let me give you an example. Do you know. Do you know this is something that people will understand? Have you ever tried washing your clothes just with softener. So forget about don’t add detergent. Just add softener. Right. And you. And you. Let’s say you had. You had really soil clothes, Have you ever tried that? No, but it’s not gonna work. No. I mean, it comes out smelling nice. It comes out soft, but the stains are going to be there. Yeah. Largely. Okay. Why? Because softeners are quants.

Matthew Rooda 00:53:29 Really? Yeah. A softener is a quote.

Jose Ramirez 00:53:31 Yeah. A softener is a quaternary ammonium molecule.

Jose Ramirez 00:53:34 Now the length of the tail is a bit longer in a softener because that, that that gives you sort of that softness in between the fibers because the quad absorbs to the fibers. Right. But it doesn’t clean. The stain will be there. Right. So that’s why you need a detergent. You need a detergent. And what is the detergent? The detergent is made of either non ionic or anionic. In other words, no charge or negatively charged.

Matthew Rooda 00:54:01 Surfactants neutralizing against the. Yeah.

Jose Ramirez 00:54:04 And you know what are the surfactants that are in the intervention mixture. Largely anionic negatively charged and non ionic.

Matthew Rooda 00:54:16 So do you need a detergent when you use an intervention or is it its own?

Jose Ramirez 00:54:20 Its own detergent? That’s what that’s what I’m trying to, to explain in in, in, in in a little bit more clear fashion is, is that when you’re using that, you’re going to remember the 10 million or the million particles that we talked about? There’s going to be like a two, a two log reduction just by detergents, just by removal.

Jose Ramirez 00:54:39 You know, and so now you’re now you’re 10 million. Now that becomes 100,000. Now the 100,000. When the disinfection action comes now that becomes less than ten. Right.

Matthew Rooda 00:54:52 So so it’s kind of like if for the layman it’s the two and one. Yes. It’s you’re getting the combo. You’re not adding on the operational time and headache of doing both. Yes. but you’re getting the benefit of both. Exactly.

Jose Ramirez 00:55:05 Exactly. Yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:55:07 Very cool. That’s very cool.

Jose Ramirez 00:55:10 So, remember, you know, it’s a whenever, whenever anybody will say, well, you know, this the this co-op product cleans very well. yeah. I mean, remember that example of the softener, right? And so these softeners that typically they the the molecule is very, very, very similar. and in general positively charged surfactants do not clean well.

Matthew Rooda 00:55:36 So I think that’s a good place to to end on. And so, I’m going to ask you some rapid fire questions I made last time, but I will ask you first.

Matthew Rooda 00:55:45 Is there any final thoughts or do you think we we hit on everything for for everybody listening.

Jose Ramirez 00:55:52 I think we’ve covered a lot of what I wanted to cover. I think we got into some of the, rabbit holes concerning, let’s say efficacy, you know, of, of newer technologies versus older generations and hopefully that, you know, those quantitative examples kind of give people an idea of what the what the real risks in and the real world are, right? As opposed to, you know, something that’s, let’s say, meeting the EPA laboratory tests, if you will.

Matthew Rooda 00:56:21 Yeah. I’m hoping for everyone listening that the rabbit holes helped you as much as it did me. On understanding a bit of the deeper components there of how that’s all made up.

Jose Ramirez 00:56:30 Yeah, yeah, we didn’t get into, And this is all I remember. This is all related to the chemistry. Right? So we didn’t get into the implications on wastewater treatment and what happens when you apply some of these, especially these technologies with that runoff that goes into the lagoon or goes into the municipality.

Matthew Rooda 00:56:48 But we hit that in the last one. I think a little bit.

Jose Ramirez 00:56:50 We did, we did.

Matthew Rooda 00:56:51 People should go listen to that. If you’re interested in its impact on the the lagoons.

Jose Ramirez 00:56:54 Yeah for sure.

Matthew Rooda 00:56:56 Awesome. So from a rapid fire standpoint, we’ll hit some unique ones here. what is your favorite actor, actress or musician?

Jose Ramirez 00:57:08 Oh, wow. That’s like, I have to, I have to I have to narrow it to one. I probably I would say George Clooney is probably my favorite actor. Yeah. Musician is a band. I like the band. Rush. Canadian band. Yeah. I just think it’s just like that. The three people are probably at one point the most talented individual at their instrument. You know. So. Yeah. Rush.

Matthew Rooda 00:57:33 And then if you’re out and and you have all the options in the world for desserts, what’s your go to?

Jose Ramirez 00:57:42 I would say apple pie. Yeah. Especially my mom’s apple pie is just. Oh yeah. Yeah, yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:57:50 How does she do it. How is it I just have that caramel on it or not? Like what? Anything different? Or is it the crust and the. Everything’s just so perfect, I think.

Jose Ramirez 00:57:57 I think it’s the way she cooks the apple and the caramelization. Okay. Yeah, the inside is. Oh, yeah. It’s the best. Yeah yeah yeah, yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:58:05 And then what for you is the best form of relaxation. Like when you have your free time or you’re going on vacation, what allows you to just check out effortlessly?

Jose Ramirez 00:58:17 Oh, you know, I love running and I love cycling. especially when it’s, trails in the woods. Right. And so I live. I live in the Chicago suburbs, so I don’t live in the city, but I live where I live, partly because I have easy access to the trails and the woods. And, yeah, whenever I feel overwhelmed or tired or something, I actually I just go for a quick run out, especially in the early morning.

Jose Ramirez 00:58:43 You know, you have you listen to the to the trees and, you know, that’s I would say to me that that just recharges my batteries tremendously. Yeah.

Matthew Rooda 00:58:52 Do you do that competitively, triathlons or any of that stuff or just recreationally?

Jose Ramirez 00:58:55 Nah. Recreationally, when the minute you start sort of putting, structure into it, then it then it’s not really fun.

Matthew Rooda 00:59:01 Yeah. Yeah yeah yeah, yeah. Fair. Well, thank you for being a guest on the podcast. It’s been a pleasure to have you today.

Jose Ramirez 00:59:07 Oh, it’s my pleasure, Matthew. I’m happy to be here.